top of page
Q & A With Gedolim
A Deep Dive into the Wisdom of the Gedolim, Addressing Today's Most Pressing Questions


Tea, Trash, a Bris, and a Bookshelf
Tea in a Kli Shlishi Question May I make tea in a kli shlishi on Shabbos? Rav Auerbach The Chazon Ish ruled that kalei habishul are cooked even in a kli shlishi. However, the Mishnah Berurah (318:47) rules that it is permitted to put bread into a kli shlishi, and we do not say that there is bishul after afiyah. There are those who claim that there is a difference between that halacha and the halacha of kalei habishul, bringing proof from the fact that the Mishnah Berurah (ibi
Aug 33 min read


To Blech or Not to Blech: This Is the Question
Question Last Shabbos, my wife and I went to a tzimmer (an Israeli bungalow), and we forgot to bring a blech. We got to the tzimmer right before Shabbos, and my wife, who went to a choshuve seminary and knows halacha very well, ruled that we would have to forgo putting the half-cooked cholent on the fire that Shabbos. I myself learned in yeshiva, and I never really studied halacha, but I did learn Maseches Shabbos with Daf Yomi. It seems to me that the halachos listed there a
Aug 34 min read


Reciting Haazinu with the Tisha B’Av Selichos
Question For the past 20 years, I have been hosting a minyan on Tisha B’Av in my home. During the minyan, we recite 13 selected Kinnos, all connected to a central theme, which is explained at length before they are recited by the rov associated with the minyan. This year’s theme is shirah—that just as we sing Hallel on the chag, so too, on Tisha B’Av, the Kinnos we recite are actually a form of shirah. The Kinnos place into perspective all of the tzaros that Klal Yisroel has
Aug 33 min read


Reciting the Brocha of She’asah Li Neis Outside of a Church
Question My brother and I are baalei teshuvah and we have a very interesting question to ask the rov. Before my father married our mother, he was engaged to a non-Jew. When his fiancée discovered that my father was Jewish, she got cold feet. Although he was able to convince her to go ahead with the wedding, she insisted that before they married, he first had to get baptized, Rachmana litzlan. My father very much wanted to marry this woman and he agreed. On the day the baptism
Jul 303 min read


Meat at a Siyum During the Nine Days
Question I have seen that people are very lenient regarding eating meat at a siyum during the Nine Days, and that even people who were not directly connected to the learning eat meat. I would like to know the parameters of this leniency. For example, if someone made a siyum in a restaurant, may everyone in the restaurant eat meat, even if they had no connection whatsoever to the siyum? On a similar note, I have been learning Sefer Yehoshua with a chavrusa once a week for over
Jul 223 min read


Tefillah Restart
Question Every day, I catch Mincha at a shtiebel. There are a lot of minyanim going on simultaneously, and each minyan can hear what is going on in the other one. I have the following questions: 1. If I hear the minyan next door reciting Kaddish or Kedusha, but I have already started Shemoneh Esrei by saying “Hashem sefosai tiftoch,” can I answer Kaddish or Kedusha and then go back to my Shemoneh Esrei, or is it forbidden for me to answer? 2. If after reciting “Hashem sefosai
Jul 163 min read


Teshuvah for a Seven-Year-Old Robin Hood
Question My son is seven years old and is highly active. We were a little surprised on Purim when he decided to dress up like Robin Hood, who was famous for stealing from the rich and giving to the poor. When he started stealing candies from the local grocery store and distributing them to his friends, we retroactively understood why he had chosen that particular costume. We are doing everything possible to direct our son on the right path and to channel his energy into more
Jul 13 min read


Reishis Hageiz in “The Shteitel”
Question I am in the process of building a moshav called “The Shteitel” right outside of Yerushalayim, next to the neighborhood of Kochav Hashachar. The moshav will, be’ezras Hashem, have a kollel, and our goal is for English-speaking Jews to settle and live a simpler and more Torahdike life, like we once had in the shtetel. I would like to ask the rov for advice on how we can set up “The Shteitel” and its kollel in a way that will facilitate maximum growth in avodas Hashem f
May 314 min read


Skipping Tachanun During the Seven Days After Shavuos
Question I am the gabbai of my local minyan, and I really connect to the tefillah of Tachanun. When we skip it, I feel like I am missing an important part of the davening, but of course I bow my head to the halachic ruling. If there is a baal bris or a chosson davening in our minyan on a weekday, they let me know beforehand. Right after Shemoneh Esrei, I give a klopp on the bimah, and everyone knows that this means we will not be reciting Tachanun that day. Once we get to Siv
May 245 min read


The Life-Saving Power of Pesukei Dezimra
Question I often find myself coming late to tefillah and, as a result, I have to skip most of Pesukei Dezimra. How much effort should I spend reciting Pesukei Dezimra in full? Thank you. Yanky Rav Auerbach The Mishnah in Brachos (30b) notes that the Chassidim Harishonim would spend an hour preparing before and after each of the three tefillos, and then spend an hour davening, nine hours in total. Even though nine hours is a significant amount of time spent davening, the Gema
May 133 min read


From Rashbi’s Kever to a Bris: Lag BaOmer and Practical Halacha”
Rav Shimon Bar Yochai and the Baal Shem of Michelstadt Question I was recently in Germany to daven by the kever of the Baal Shem of Michelstadt. I got there late at night, and since I had not davened Maariv, I davened Maariv right next to the kever. Afterwards, I thought that perhaps it was not right to daven so close to the kever. After further introspection, I came to the conclusion that since so many people daven tefillos by Rav Shimon Bar Yochai’s kever on Lag Ba’omer, th
May 33 min read


Uvdin Dechol Sheilas
We are a group of 15 Persian bnei Torah from the Tila Shul in Los Angeles who came to Eretz Yisroel to learn in Rabbi Travis’ kollel for a week, specifically to study the sugya of uvdin dechol b’iyun . We have a number of questions about the sugya that we would like to ask Rav Auerbach. Traveling in a Luxury Railroad Car on Shabbos Question We studied a teshuvah from the Chasam Sofer (6:97), who rules that riding on a train is uvdin dechol , because it takes a person
Apr 213 min read
Browse by Topic
bottom of page